Sam Stites

Introduction to Scala Traits

07 March 2015 - Mountain View

I’ve been digging into scala more and more. Inspired by Horstmann’s Scala for the Impatient, I’m writing a series of posts on parts of Scala I find interesting. Some of the examples I show will come directly from Horstmann, but only because they’re pretty great examples. I highly recommend the book.

Scala traits are pretty cool. They’re basically the same as interfaces in Java. Except for the fact that they’re a lot more flexible than interfaces and they’ve been made to address the multiple inheritence problem which is missing in Java. Austin (coworker) says that it’s the closest thing he’s seen to multiple inherience done in C++.

Lets start with why multiple inheritence done in Java. Mutliple inheritence is a powerful feature and is simple to think about when you have completely different classes — but things get crazy when you start to inherit from similar ones. Properties overlap and, soon, you have seven different definitions of an ‘overridden’ function.

This is classically defined in The Diamond Problem (or the ‘deadly diamond of death’ - wikipedia): Diamond Inheritance from wikipedia

In Java, they ignore this problem completely. You can only inherit from one abstract class — although you can bind your class to any number of interfaces as you’d like. In C++, you would have to redefine any base class defintions to clear things up. In Scala, you would use traits.

As I mentioned, traits are a lot like java interfaces. In fact you can use them in the exact same way. However you can declare definitions, properties, or methods in both the concrete and the abstract. Even alongside each other!

Methods declared, but not defined are implicitly defined as abstract:

trait Foo {
  def bar(x: String)     // abstract definition
  def baz(y: String) {}  // concrete definition

With regards to mutliple inheritance, you can simply chain traits with the with modifier:

class X extends TraitA with TraitB with TraitC { /* ... */ }

Note that the compiler reads this as class X extending TraitA with TraitB with TraitC. Traits will inherit from eachother in FILO (first in, last out) fashion. So if - in the above example - TraitA, TraitB, and TraitC all override the method definition def bar(x:String) {} in TraitA, then class X will inherit bar from TraitC.

Some other notes on scala’s traits:

Finally keep in mind that, when refactoring traits with concrete behaviour, all classes inheriting from that trait must be recompiled.